| 24th November 2007 10:33 AM |
|
|
| steel driving hammer |
We know Mick is on fire so I figure not to include him.
But out of, Robert Plant, Rod Stewart, Keith Richards & Bob Dylan.
As of today, I'd say, in order...
Robert.
Rod.
Keith & Bob tied for last.
Hard to rate but these 4 are slipping away...
But Keith n' Bob write music today to fit their voice no?
I mean they can all put out a rocking tune but singing to it, would be the struggle.
Do you think they both write to accommodate their voice.
Edited by your mother baby...
[Edited by steel driving hammer] |
| 24th November 2007 01:01 PM |
|
|
| LoveinVainRonnie |
None of these guys sing how they used to but I guess I'd go....
I'm not sure about Robert Plant since I don't listen to him...but I guess his voice would sound the less worn here.
Then Rod, Keith, and Bob.
[Edited by LoveinVainRonnie] |
| 24th November 2007 01:03 PM |
|
|
| Gazza |
quote:
steel driving hammer wrote:
But Keith n' Bob write music today to fit their voice no?
I mean they can all put out a rocking tune but singing to it, would be the struggle.
Dylan cant sing to a rock song? His last album obviously passed you by, then...
quote:
steel driving hammer wrote:
But Keith n' Bob write music today to fit their voice no?
Doesn't everyone?
[Edited by Gazza] |
| 24th November 2007 01:04 PM |
|
|
| steel driving hammer |
Yeah, out of those 4, Plant has the best for the kind of music he does and still try to keep up w/ it.
Plant is still very good at ballads.
|
| 24th November 2007 01:06 PM |
|
|
| steel driving hammer |
quote:
Gazza wrote:
Dylan cant sing to a rock song? His last album obviously passed you by, then...
- It actually did pass me by. Never got it.
Doesn't everyone?
- Well I guess.
|
| 24th November 2007 03:49 PM |
|
|
| fireontheplatter |
rod stewart....still sounds awesome today
keith richards....love his slower songs like hicory wind
robert plant....always a great singer
his bobness........love this guy, but he doesn't sound all that good to me live these days. |
| 24th November 2007 07:11 PM |
|
|
| gotdablouse |
Macca's wonderful voice is now very hoarse... |
| 25th November 2007 02:51 AM |
|
|
| IanBillen |
Did Bob Dylan ever sound good...lol?
However he is a great song writer and somewhat an innovator.
A living Legend that has seen it all and done a whole hell of a lot.
One of a kind.
Ian |
| 25th November 2007 03:11 AM |
|
|
| Child of the Moon |
Plant sounds much better now than he did back during the Zeppelin IV/Houses of the Holy days. He sounds much more earthy now, not so much like the sound of two cats fucking.
The loss of the "old" Keith Richards voice is one of the most tragic things to ever happen. That guy had such a pretty voice back then. A constant reminder of why I don't smoke. |
| 25th November 2007 07:08 AM |
|
|
| Taptrick |
Did someone say Keith still writes music?
|
| 25th November 2007 04:33 PM |
|
|
| Sioux |
[quote]IanBillen wrote:
Did Bob Dylan ever sound good...lol?
However he is a great song writer and somewhat an innovator.
A living Legend that has seen it all and done a whole hell of a lot.
One of a kind.
Ian [/quote}
Bob sounded different on a lot of projects. That gutteral, almost "talking" singing he did/does was something he used
for the place he was in at the time. He could sing in a more mellow, conventional voice when he wanted to. My husband, a huge fan, went to see him a couple of months ago and said it's just sad now. He won't go back to another concert. Sometimes I guess it just IS time to stop touring...
[Edited by Sioux] |
| 25th November 2007 04:52 PM |
|
|
| guitarman53 |
No Keith for me, he's got a terrible voice, the thing about Bob Dylan, he's been considered one of the all time worst singers of all time, but I loved his early stuff like "Like A Rolling Stone" it would have to be Robert Plant, if he can pull of the vocals he did years ago, he's the winner. |
| 25th November 2007 06:25 PM |
|
|
| MemoFromTinaTurner |
Plant's voice is shot. |
