|
|
| L&A |
Following a referendum on Radio 21, Classic Rock by Marc Ysaye (Belgium, French speaking), here are the best 100 albums since the beginning of Rock.
Two observations:
- First Rolling Stones album ranks (Sticky Fingers) only at position... 22 ! In 1997, first RS album ranked at row 7 !
- ... but at least 5 Rolling Stones albums are listed !
To debate !
1 Queen A night at the opera 1975
2 Pink Floyd Dark side of the moon 1973
3 Led Zeppelin Led Zeppelin IV 1971
4 Deep Purple Made in Japan 1973
5 Radiohead OK computer 1995
6 The Beatles Sergeant Pepper's lonely Haert's club band 1967
7 Pink Floyd The wall 1979
8 Genesis The lamb lies down on brodway 1974
9 The Beatles Double Blanc 1968
10 David Bowie The rise & fall of Ziggy Stardust and The Spiders from Mars 1972
11 Led Zeppelin Led Zeppelin II 1969
12 Supertramp Crime of the century 1974
13 Led Zeppelin Led Zeppelin III 1970
14 Nirvana Nevermind 1990
15 Pink Floyd Whish you were Here 1975
16 Queen Sheer Heart attack 1974
17 Genesis Selling England by the pound 1973
18 Yes Close to the Edge 1973
19 U2 Thge Joshua Tree 1987
20 The Beatles Abbey Road 1969
21 AC/DC Back in Black 1980
22 The Rolling Stones Sticky Fingers 1971
23 Queen News of the world 1977
24 Led Zeppelin Pysical Graffitti 1975
25 The Who Who's next 1971
26 Jimi Hendrix Electric lady land 1968
27 The Rolling Stones Beggar's Banquet 1968
28 Smashing Pumpkins Melon Collie & the Infinite sadness 1995
29 Genesis Foxtrot 1972
30 AC/DC Highway to hell 1979
31 Sex Pistols Never mind the Bollock's 1977
32 Deep Purple Machine head 1971
33 Deep Purple In Rock 1971
34 Dire Straits Brothers in Arms 1985
35 Peter Frampton Peter frampton comes alive 1976
37 The Doors LA Woman 1971
38 Alice in Chains Dirt 1991
39 Crosby Stills Nash & Young D�j� vu 1971
40 Neil Young Harvest 1972
41 The velvet underground & Nico The velvet underground & Nico 1969
42 Fleetwood Mac Rumours 1977
43 The Clash London Calling 1979
44 The Who Tommy 1969
45 Eagles Hotel california 1976
46 Simple Minds New Gold dream 1982
47 Jethro Tull Aqaulung 1971
48 Led Zeppelin Led Zeppelin I 1975
49 Depeche Mode Violator 1990
50 The Beatles Revolver 1966
51 Jimi Hendrix Are you experienced 1967
52 Red Hot Chili Pepper Californication 1999
53 U2 Achtung Baby 1991
54 Smashing Pumpkins Siammese dream 1993
55 Pink Floyd Meddle 1970
56 Queen The game 1980
57 Depeche Mode Music for the masses 1987
58 Jeff Buckley Grace 1994
59 John Lennon Imagine 1971
60 Radiohead Kid A 2000
61 Supertramp Breakfast in America 1979
62 The cranberries No need to Argue 1994
63 Bob Dylan Highway 61 Revisited 1965
64 Bruce Spingsteen Born in the USA 1985
65 Van Halen Van halen 1 1978
66 The Rolling Stones Get year ya ya's out 1969
67 Lenny Kravitz Let love Rule 1989
68 Queen Jazz 1978
69 Slade Slade Alive 1972
70 The Rolling Stones Let it bleed 1969
71 The Beatles Help 1964
72 Metallica Metallica 1991
73 The Rolling Stones Exile on main street 1972
74 Joy Division Closer 1980
75 Pink Floyd The piper at the gates of dawn 1967
76 The Cure Pornography 1982
77 The Doors The Doors 1967
78 Humble Pie Performance Live at the Fillmore 1971
79 Aerosmith Toys in the Attic 1975
80 Bob Dylan Blonde on Blonde 1966
81 The Cure Desintegretion 1989
82 Deus The Ideal crash 1999
83 Indochine Paradize 2001
84 King Crimson In the Court of the Crimson king 1969
85 Moby Play 1999
86 Pink Floyd Atom heart mother 1971
87 The Who Live at leeds 1970
88 Placebo Without you I'm nothing 1998
89 Slipknot IOWA 2001
90 The Smiths The Queen is dead 1986
91 U2 War 1983 �
92 Radiohead Amnesiak 2001
93 The Cure Faith 1981
94 Supertramp Even in the quitest moment 1977
95 Black Sabbath Paranoid 1969
96 Michael Jackson Thriller 1982
97 Eric Clapton Unplugged 1991
98 Led Zeppelin Remasters 1992
99 Mark Knopfler Sailing to Philadalphia 2000
100 U2 Rattle & Hum 1987 |
|
|
| jb |
Another crock of shit poll........the first 4 positions should be "Exile","LIB", "BB", and "Sticky Fingers"....with the remaining 6 positions as follows: Some Girls, GHS, IORR, Tatoo You, VL, and Black and Blue. |
|
|
| vampire |
Queen, Genesis, Pink Floyd, Supertramp, Yes? Whats wrong with those guys?
It can't be serious
|
|
|
| steel driving hammer |
Don't worry. As you well may know, every poll on the same topic is different every time it's taken.
They can't make up their minds and place bands on top who they think or seem are popular at the time the poll was done. Same song, different verse.
In other words, they don't know who's boots to Lick.
The Stones don't even belong on that poll, if you know what I mean. |
|
|
| jb |
This is an French poll, isn't it?
[Edited by jb] |
|
|
| vampire |
Can I think if was American J Lo would be in first? 
|
|
|
| jb |
No Vampire.....it would be some piece of crap like Faith Hill, Shainia Twain, etc.....Americans have , perhaps, worse taste than the British.....After all, we made BackStreet Boys, En Sync, Britney, etc....We are a pop driven nation who live for songs like "macarena", "achy-breaky heart", and the theme from "Titanic"(as well as the Lion King).
[Edited by jb] |
|
|
| vampire |
I think you forgot to mention the "brows"
Dr Dre, Snoop Dog, Cypress Hill.........
Ai, Ai
Ai, Ai
|
|
|
| jb |
Oh yes...anything that can allow white surbuban kids to pretend their black is big here!!!!!!!!!!!!!! "Keep it real" Vamp!!!! |
|
|
| Joey |
"Keep it real" Vamp!!!! "
Josh ......................Had my Ceder plate last evening but the anchovies made me sick so I could finish the Sea Scallops with Plum Sauce .
Shiver .......................
Developing ...................
Bunny Joe !
|
|
|
| vampire |
quote:
jb wrote:
No Vampire.....it would be some piece of crap like Faith Hill, Shainia Twain, etc.....Americans have , perhaps, worse taste than the British.....After all, we made BackStreet Boys, En Sync, Britney, etc....We are a pop driven nation who live for songs like "macarena", "achy-breaky heart", and the theme from "Titanic"(as well as the Lion King).
[Edited by jb]
Well, if you say, who am I to disagree?
|
|
|
| jb |
Joey, is Max's last name "Weinberg"? |
|
|
| Joey |
" Joey, is Max's last name "Weinberg"?
No , I believe he told me it's " Cohen " !
But he was drunk and high that evening so who the Hell really knows ..............................
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ - ac - ky !
|
|
|
| jb |
Thanks.....Do you know any Lipshitz' |
|
|
| L&A |
No JB, it's from Belgium, you know
But I think it could be the same in France or in the US, when you make a referendum with a "Classic Rock" audience, except maybe dEUS (a fantastic Belgian band) or Yes (one of Marc Ysaye favourite bands, together with Led Zeppelin).
And I think we should analyse those results...
If you ask to someone who is not a hard-fan of the Stones, which is the best "all times" best album, I think you will have 2 reactions:
- Security: the biggest top-of-mind classical product, such as Pink Floyd or the Beatles
- Actuality: the latest "newest classic rock band", and those are moving from one year to the other. For example Smashing Pumpkins, Radiohead, Metallica, Joy Division...
That's maybe the reason why I'm still such a huge fan of the Stones: No Security, but always there
To compare, here's the top 100 from 1997:
1 Pink Floyd Dark side of the moon 73
2 The beatles Sergeant Pepper's 67
3 Led Zeppelin Led Zeppelin 4 71
4 Deep Purple Made in Japan 73
5 queen A night at the opera 74
6 The who Who 's next 71
7 The Rolling Stones Sticky fingers 71
8 The Beatles Double Blanc 68
9 Jimi Hendrix Electric lady land 68
10 Genesis The lamb lies down on brodway 74
11 Led Zeppelin Led Zeppelin II 69
12 Led Zeppelin Led Zeppelin III 70
13 Deep Purple In rock 70
14 Crosby Stills Nash & young Deja vu 70
15 Neil Young Harvest 72
16 David Bowie The rise & fall of Ziggy Stardust 72
17 Peter Frampton Frampton comes alive 76
18 The Eagles Hotel California 76
19 The Doors LA Woman 71
20 Genesis Foxtrot 72
21 The Beatles Abbey Road 69
22 Supertramp Crime of the century 74
23 Pink Floyd The wall 79
24 Nirvana Nevermind 91
25 Yes Close to the edge 72
26 Jimi Hendrix Are you experienced 67
27 King Crimson In the court of the crimson king 69
28 Led Zeppelin Led Zeppelin 69
29 Pink Floyd Whish you were here 75
30 Genesis Selling england by the pound 73
31 The Doors The Doors 67
32 The Rolling Stones Beggar's Banquet 68
33 John Lennon Imagine 71
34 Ac-Dc Highway to hell 79
35 Fleetwood Mac Rumours 76
36 The Who Tommy 68
37 Jethro Tull Aqualung 71
38 The Rolling Stones Exile on main street 72
39 Deep Purple Machine head 71
40 U2 The Josua tree 87
41 Sex Pistols Nevermlnd the bollocks 77
� Derek & the Dominos Layla and assorted love songs 70
42 Black Sabbath Paranoid 69
43 The Rolling Stones Let it bleed 69
44 Dire straits Dire straits 78
45 The Clash London calling 79
46 Pink Floyd Meddle 71
47 Led Zeppelin Physycal graffiti 75
48 Bob Dylan Blonde on blonde 66
49 Peter Gabriel So 87
50 Nirvana Unplugged 93
51 Lou Reed Rock 'n roll animal 75
52 Van Halen Van Halen I 76
53 Dire Straits Brothers in arms 85
54 Pronounced Lynyrd Skynyrd Lynyrd Skynyrd 73
55 The police Regatta de Blanc 80
56 Santana Abraxas 69
57 U2 War 85
58 Supertramp Breakfast in America 79
59 Creedence Clearwater Revival Cosmos Factory 68
60 Bruce Springsteen Born in the USA 84
� Simple Minds New gold dream 82
61 Bob Dylan Highway 61 Revisited 65
62 Guns'n Roses Appetite for destruction 87
63 Michael Jackson Thriller 83
64 Pink Floyd Atom heart mother 70
65 Led Zeppelin The song remains the same 76
66 The Rolling Stones Get year ya ya's out 69
67 The Who Live at Leeds 70
68 Clapton Unplugged 92
69 Machiavel Mechanical Moonbeams 78
70 Yes Fragile 71
71 Slade Slade alive 72
72 Metallica Metallica 91
73 Humble Pie Performance Live at the Fillmore 71
74 Ac-Dc Back in black 80
75 Queen Sheer heart attack 74
76 Rainbow Rainbow 75
77 Pearl jam Ten 91
78 Toto 4 82
79 REM Out of time 93
80 Mike Oldfield Tubular bells 73
81 Peter Gabriel Gabriel I 76
82 Meat Loaf Bat out of hell 77
83 Allman Brothers Band LIve at the Fillmore 73
84 Phil Collins Face value 80
85 Emmerson Lake & Palmer Tarkus 71
86 Velvet Underground Velvet Undeground & Nico 67
87 Queen Innuendo 91
88 U2 Under a red blue sky 83
89 Yes Relayer 74
90 Genesis Trick of the Tail 76
91 Yes Goin' for the one 77
92 Soundtrack Woodstock 70
93 The Rolling Stones It's only rock'nroll 74
94 Supertramp Even in the quitest moment 77
95 The Beatles Let it be 70
96 The Beatles Revolver 65
97 U2 The unforgettable Fire 84
98 U2 Rattle & hum 88
99 ZZ Top Eliminator 83 |
|
|
| Joey |
" Thanks.....Do you know any Lipshitz' "
No , will " Goldberg " suffice .............?
|
|
|
| jb |
That a ludicrous comment....you obviously like Pink Floyd much more and it shows. |
|
|
| vampire |
Well Lazy, imo, "Dark Side..." is umbereable
|
|
|
| jb |
unbearable piece of shit..how can you claim that the Stones are your favorite band and pick another bands album as better than any of the Stones....this really amazes me and i no longer can take anything this person says seriously. |
|
|
| Moonisup |
Josh, we are in a special group to understand the stones music!
Not everyone gets that, and still places that horrible foursome above the stones |
|
|
| jb |
Hi Rik!!! Yes, even people who post here like the Beatles and Pink Floyd more....I would like to think someone who posts on a Stones board would think atleast one of their albums was better than "dark side of the moon"..I always hated Pink Floyd and their boring fucking music. |
|
|
| Lazy Bones |
Well, Vampire, you have the right to your opinion. I respect that and I'm mature enough to not challenge it - unlike some others.
|
|
|
| Pattie |
I like Pink Floyd and Queen, but the Rolling Stones is the best band in the world. They�ve always been the best band in the world |
|
|
| vampire |
Viva! |
|
|
| steel driving hammer |
Sharks Will Cry...
Back on you Baaaiiiiiiiie! |
|
|
| Moonisup |
I love the Floyd songs 'wish you where here" and shine on you crazy diamond |
|
|
| steel driving hammer |
quote:
Moonisup wrote:
I love the Floyd songs 'wish you where here" and shine on you crazy diamond
Ok that is IT! I can't STAND that Chuck picture ANY LONGER! LOL!
SHOOOOOF!
And that fucking shirt he's wearing too!
We've had enough Rik. |
|
|
| vampire |
quote:
Moonisup wrote:
I love the Floyd songs 'wish you where here" and shine on you crazy diamond
I forgive you  |
|
|
| Moonisup |
I see forgiveness and a call to let chuck leave
why am I forgiven?
?and chuck can't go |
|
|
| vampire |
quote:
Moonisup wrote:
I see forgiveness and a call to let chuck leave
why am I forgiven?
?and chuck can't go
Because the Pink Floyd stuff.
(And leave "Virginia" Alone).
But Its not ME complaining about Chuck. You know, i like him...He even sent me his album
|
CHAT
ROOM aka THE FUN HOUSE] [
RESTROOMS]