|
|
| Bruno Stone |
In that version ( as in the entire tour ) Keith is playing bass and Bill is on the guitar, is this right?
I heard Love You Live for the first time last week, headphones, enjoying the air conditioning in a very pleasant CD store here. I was crazy about the guitars sound, perfect.
Loved Tumblin Dice in slow motion, and Preston performance in it.
But the question is: in FF, Ronnie is on the wha wha, right?
Is Bill on the other guitar? |
|
|
| beer |
Jagger on guitar, Ronnie on bass, Bill on keyboard.
|
|
|
| Gazza |
Lots of studio overdubs on that song, however, although the vocals are intact (with overdubbed echo effects)
There are seven cuts in the version thats on the album, comprising over two minutes from the original version
Source : "Maybe It's Live" by Walter Schappi ("Charlie is Good tonight" fanzine) |
|
|
| mac_daddy |
quote:
Gazza wrote:
Lots of studio overdubs on that song, however, although the vocals are intact (with overdubbed echo effects)
There are seven cuts in the version thats on the album, comprising over two minutes from the original version
Source : "Maybe It's Live" by Walter Schappi ("Charlie is Good tonight" fanzine)
the stones are really neurotic about that - they overdub (heavily) all of their live albums it seems... |
|
|
| jpenn11 |
Perhaps not just albums. I read a thread a while ago about L&G having parts overdubbed though not a much as the live albums. I never went back to check the mis-syncs, but I think Happy was one of the songs claimed to have received some post-performance assistance. |
|
|
| mac_daddy |
quote:
jpenn11 wrote:
Perhaps not just albums. I read a thread a while ago about L&G having parts overdubbed though not a much as the live albums. I never went back to check the mis-syncs, but I think Happy was one of the songs claimed to have received some post-performance assistance.
sh*t, the l & g i have is filled with missyncs. do NOT go back and look for them. take it from someone who does this all too often - it is a real depressing thing to do, because once you train your eyes and ears to notice flaws, you see/hear them everywhere. unless your copy of l&g is much better than mine - in that case, we have to talk 
(ot: did you see the thorogood source i just put up..? it is another cassette transfer from the tapes t&a sent me - you would dig it.) |
|
|
| Child of the Moon |
The line-up on FF, as I know it:
Jagger: rhythm guitar
Richards: wah-wah
Wood: bass
Wyman: synth
etc.
As far as dubs on L&G go, I know that Happy definitely benefits - if you watch the video, half the time you hear Keith singing, he's nowhere near the microphone. Same with Jagger on that one. Sad, because that's a really great version. |
|
|
| beer |
Thats the way it's played.COTM, do ya have the LA 75 video? It's interesting.
I haven't watched LnG in a long time, but i have a damn good version of it, and i thought the out of sync parts were due to poor editing, not overdubs. i'll have to watch it again.
=
|
|
|
| corgi37 |
I always loved FF on Love you Live. I always loved Love you Live. Then Gazza pointed out all the dubs and cuts and mystical things they did to the damn thing, and now i am dissolutioned!
I feel....dirty.
Violated, even.
Why would they do that? Cut 2 minutes off a song, i mean. And, why wasnt it re-instated on the re-mastered version?
But, hang on, was LYL released re-mastered? |
|
|
| texile |
me too corgi........
i don't need to know this shit -
just listen to australia, 73 and you will believe again.
hey i fucked by posting this reply as a new thread .......
don't click on it! |
|
|
| Gazza |
quote:
mac_daddy wrote:
sh*t, the l & g i have is filled with missyncs. do NOT go back and look for them. take it from someone who does this all too often - it is a real depressing thing to do, because once you train your eyes and ears to notice flaws, you see/hear them everywhere. unless your copy of l&g is much better than mine - in that case, we have to talk
there IS a boot DVD version of L&G where the sound (upgraded) has been dubbed on from another source, and whilst its done very well, theres a few bits where it doesnt quite synch. Maybe thats the version you have?
However, theres quite a few "mis synched" (if theres such a term) overdubs on commercially released Stones video releases. |
|
|
| corgi37 |
I only have a very worn VHS copy. 1st tape i bought actully. Paid $70.00 in 82! Whats that now? $600? hahaha.
There is a weird bit during SFM. Something wonky happened there. |
|
|
| Soldatti |
I love this song, the original version.
The best tune on IORR. |
|
CHAT
ROOM aka THE FUN HOUSE] [
RESTROOMS]